Skip to main content

THINGS YOU DON'T SAY AT A DISABILITY HEARING

Most claims for Social Security disability will wind up before an Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) for a hearing.  The judge will ask questions involving the following broad areas:

  • Why you believe you are not able to work.
  • Your past work history (in some detail).
  • Your current living and family situation. 
  • Your limitations in activities of daily living. 

Here are a few general rules I ask my clients to follow during questioning:

1.  Tell the truth.  Nothing causes more problems than lying.

2.  Don't exaggerate, and don't minimize.   

3.  Don't volunteer information you are aren't asked about.  Just answer the question, and STOP.

4.  Never answer a question you don't understand.  Ask for clarification.

5.  Use terms that are well defined or mean the same thing to everyone.  Avoid vague terms like:  sometimes, now and then, not much, a whole lot, not very often, etc.  Better to use terms such as:  about twice a week, about 30 to 40 feet, less than 10 pounds, or 2 or 3 times per day.

Here are some statements you try never to make at a hearing:

  • My pain on a scale of 1 to 10 is always a 10.  It never gets better and nothing helps.
  • You have family members receiving disability or unemployment benefits (unless you are asked).
  • You have a bad alcohol or drug problem (unless you are asked).
  • You haven't followed your doctor's advice or you don't take the medications your doctor has prescribed.
  • Nobody will hire you; there are no jobs in your town.
  • You can't work because you take care of a sick family member.
  • You can't work because you don't have transportation.
  • You don't have the skills or experience needed for a good job. 

A judge simply will not believe that your pain is always a 10 and nothing ever makes it better.  Constant pain on a 10 out of 10 scale would require hospitalization and the judge won't find the allegation credible. This sounds like an exaggeration.

Having family members on disability or unemployment benefits may indicate a family who relies on government benefits and doesn't have much incentive to work.

Failure to follow a doctor's advice or take your medications is, in itself, a reason to deny a claim.  Perhaps if you followed your treatment plan you would be better and wouldn't be disabled.

Nobody will hire you, or there are no jobs in your hometown-- are NOT disability problems.  They are employment problems and Social Security doesn't pay for employment problems.  Also, the judge may assume that if there were jobs available, you would go to work, thus you are not disabled.

If you are able to care for a sick family member, you may also be able to hold a job.  Also, this implies that you could work but have a reason other than disability that prevents working. Always a bad argument.  Don't go there.

Lack of transportation is never a disability or reason to award a disability benefit.  The assumption is that if you had transportation you could and would be working.  Thus, you are not disabled and Social Security does not pay for any other issue--just disability due to a severe physical or mental impairment. Transportation simply isn't considered.

Not having good job skills, past experience or job training is not a disability.  It may be an employment problem but the solution to it is vocational training or going to school to learn new skills.  The solution is not disability and there is no disability benefit for lack of skills, or lack of training.  This will kill your case right off the bat.  It basically says, "I am physically and mentally able to work but I'm not working due to a lack of job training or experience." This is NOT a disability and it is not covered by the Social Security Act.

The judge wants to see a claimant who has a long, steady work history.  The claimant wants to work, is willing to work, but has a severe physical and/or mental impairment that makes full-time work impossible. The judge also will want to see objective medical evidence (doctor's records) that proves the nature, severity and duration of the impairment(s).  When did the impairment begin?  What body parts are affected? How severe is it?   What restrictions does the impairment cause in your ability to perform work-like activities, such as sitting, standing, walking, lifting, reaching, kneeling, crouching, crawling, grasping, handling, balancing, etc.?  

You must be truthful at your hearing.  If a judge asks you about any topic, you must answer truthfully.  However, you are not required to volunteer information just to hurt your case.  

For example, the judge asks you if you have a drinking problem.  If you don't, simply say, "No, Your Honor."  Do not volunteer, "I had a very severe drinking problem up until six months ago.  I used to drink like a fish but I stopped drinking six months ago and I'm sober now."  Too much information that you were not asked about.

Or, if the judge asks:  "Why do you think you are not able to work?"  You reply:  "Well, my back hurts, I have poor balance, my hands are swollen from arthritis and I suffer from regular chest pain and shortness of breath.  Also, Your Honor, my wife has cancer and I'm the only one who can stay home and care for her.  She depends on me for everything."  You have stated that you have more than one reason for not working and one of them has nothing to do with your own personal disability.  This case will likely end in a denial.  Stick to your own personal disability and medical issues.

If you are represented by an advocate or attorney, he or she will instruct you on how to testify at your hearing.  You will go over things to say and things not to say--while being completely honest.  Your attorney/advocate will also help you frame your testimony so that it demonstrates eligibility under the rules and regulations of the Social Security Administration.  Remember, you may be disabled, but you will only get a check if you are disabled "under the rules and regulations of the Social Security Administration.  And they have the strictest rules in the world about what qualifies as a disability.  There are many ways to torpedo your hearing.  Prepare not to do so before you walk into the hearing room.  

______

The Forsythe Firm, Social Security advocates and attorneys, 7027 Old Madison Pike NW, Huntsville, AL.  Phone (256) 799-0297 or (256) 503-8151.  Free consultations.


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

HOW TO PRESENT YOUR DISABILIT CLAIM AT HEARING

  When you take your Social Security disability claim to hearing before a judge, there are 3 legal approaches you may try.  Not all approaches are available to every claimant.  Much depends on your age, past relevant work, education and residual functional capacity (restrictions).   Here are the 3 possible ways to be approved: 1.  Prove that you meet or equal a Listing.  Listings are specific medical impairments along with severe symptoms which Social Security will approve and pay automatically.  It isn't enough to be diagnosed with one of these conditions, you must also meet the severity of symptoms shown for each impairment. Only an approved medical source, such as a medical doctor of licensedf clinical psychologist, can certify that you meet a listing.   Note:  Most claimants who qualify for benefits will not meet a Listing.  Before you try to use this approach, become familiar with the Listings in Social Security's Blue Book at ...

SOCIAL SECURITY PAY INCREASE FOR 2025

  Social Security benefits will increase by 2.5 percent or an average of about $48 per month in 2025.   The Social Security Administration announced the COLA increase on October 10, 2024 which will take effect in January, 2025. The Part B Medicare premium (the part you pay for Medicare) also increased from $174.20 for most beneficiaries to $185 per month. I find it interesting that the government increased the Medicare premium 5.9 percent for 2025 but only gave recipients a 2.5 percent increase in benefits. If you or someone you love needs Social Security disability (SSDI) benefits, contact Charles W. Forsythe at the Forsythe Firm in Huntsville, AL.  I have helped thousands of claimants get approved in the "dumpster fire" process known as Social Security disability.   We charge no fee for consultations or case evaluations.  You will never pay us a fee until after you are approved and received your lump sum past due benefits. Our fees are controlled by the S...

THE 5-STEP SEQUENTIAL PROCESS FOR DISABILITYU

Social Security uses a sequential 5-Step process to decide who is disabled. "Sequential" means that each step must be considered in order.  At each step, you may be approved or denied.  Here are the Steps: STEP 1:  Are you now gainfully employed?   If Yes, you are denied and the case closes.  If No, move to Step 2. STEP 2:  Do you have a qualifying severe impairment? If No, you are denied and the case closes.  If Yes, move to Step 3. STEP 3:  Do you meet one of Social Security's Listings? If Yes, you are approved and the process closes.  If No, move to Step 4. STEP 4:  Can you perform any of your past relevant work? If Yes, you are denied and the process closes.  If No, move to Step 5. STEP 5:  Are you able to perform any other job which exists in "significant numbers" in the U.S. economy? If Yes, you are denied.  If no, you are probably approved. Note:  The claimant's age plays a huge part in Steps 4 and 5....